With new vehicle sales and the Reserve Bank note issue for December to hand, we can update our Hard Number Indicator (HNI) of the state of the economy at year end. The economy maintained its sedate pace in December. The forecast is for more of the same in the year ahead, that is for slow but not negative growth in 2016. Our HNI serves as a useful leading indicator of the Reserve Bank Business Cycle Indicator updated only to September 2015.
The HNI and the Reserve Bank coinciding business cycle indicator measure the level of economic activity. When these are converted into rates of change, we show below that the growth rate in the HNI has been declining since 2010 and is currently barely positive and is forecast to remain barely so. It is of some consolation to notice that the weak growth outlook has not deteriorated and is forecast no to do so. The consistent way in which growth in the HNI leads the Reserve Bank cycle helps to confirm its usefulness. It has the advantage of being very up to date and based on hard numbers not sample surveys.
Sales of new vehicles of all sizes in the SA market (that make up half of the HNI) are shown below. While sales are 4% down on a year before, sales volumes, which have averaged over 50 000 units a month, must be regarded as very satisfactory, given the state of the overall economy, especially for the SA manufacturers who also delivered 337 748 units to foreign markets in 2015, 20.5% up on a year before.
The other half of the HNI is made up of the growth in the real supply of and demand for cash. These demands for cash have been growing at a real 4% p.a as we show below. However the cash cycle appears to have peaked earlier in 2015, helped by lower inflation. The demands for cash, to spend on holidays and presents, rise strongly in November and December, though growth slowed this December off a very high base established in December 2014. The growth in demands for cash in SA, despite the heavy and growing use of electronic alternatives to cash, speak eloquently of the important role the informal economy plays in SA – a role however that is not reflected in official estimates of the size of the informal sector, as about 5% only of GDP.
The outlook for domestic spending has deteriorated, with the collapse in the exchange value of the rand. Higher rand prices for goods with high import or import replacement content or export potential will further discourage spending by households. That the oil price in dollars has declined by even more than the dollar value of a rand has been a welcome source of relief for households and firms. The inflation outlook has therefore not deteriorated as much as it would ordinarily have done with a rand this heavily damaged.
Hopefully this lesser inflation outlook will help restrain the Reserve Bank from raising interest rates as much as they would otherwise have done. Higher interest rates will do little to help the rand; they have not helped the rand to date that has been driven by global and SA forces well beyond the influence of monetary policy and interest rates. However higher interest rates will be sure to add to the contractionary forces slowing the economy- and undermine further the case for investing in SA. Is it too much to hope for a sanguine Reserve Bank- one that will allow the exchange rate to absorb the economic shocks- and not to add to them? And to happily surprise the market accordingly.